Giver+11

Group 11 Type your answers here.  I think jonas’s sosciety is weird/not perfect because all age at same time like every baby born in a month are 1 at the same time. People in his sosciety don’t get to pick what they do and the elders give the people the babies and name them. Last but not lest you get smacked if you do not pronounce things right .milt

i agree with you. i wouldind be able to live there for 1 day without breaking a 'major rule'. his perfect world is just boring im picturing everything gray and dull. if you ask me, this world is a living hell on earth for me. you have no choices on ANYTHING! YOU CANT PICK OUT YOUR CLOTHES, YOU CANT MARRY SOME ONE OF YOUR CHOICE, YOU CANT CHOOSE YOUR JOB, AND YOU CANT EVEN NAME YOUR OWN CHILD!?! what kind of a world is that?OH! and by the way, you happened to spell least,society x2, one wrong. just thought i'd let you know!

question 2 response: i think that at certain times its ok to lie. if you think you could get in trouble for doing it, then dont. if your trying to keep your own personal secret, then it is ok to lie. if you think your going to get in trouble for lieing ,but its your secret, then its all up to you. :D

question 2 responce: I think it should be ok to lie at certin points in life i mean if your in a situation were you have to lie then do it but if you dont have to DON'T it's bad you realy shouldent but if your holding back a secret then it's your choice so over all i agree with you. set

question 3 response: Why wont you answer!!!!???!!! set

I think that whipping is not the best way to teach a child to behave correctly. I think it just makes them fear mistakes. I think that grounding them or a time out or something along the lines of non-physical punishment that involves losing something that they like for awhile.set

HELLO. SCHMORLANDO HERE. INTERESTING DIALOGUE YOU HAD ABOUT JONAS'S SOCIETY. YOU SPOKE ABOUT THE NEGATIVE ASPECTS OF HIS COMMUNITY, BUT WHAT ABOUT ABOUT THE GOOD PARTS? WHAT WOULD BE SOME BENEFITS OF LIVING IN A SOCIETY LIKE JONAS'S? THINK ABOUT THIS WHILE I STUDY MY LATEST MOVIE SCRIPT. \ The thing that led up to everything being the same is that racism and they thought that it would be good if everything was the same but there is only one thing wrong with their plan… it worked so now everybody is the same only the giver and the receiver are the same.milt

the only thing good about their society is that there is no war or pain. their society is completly unfair. i read ahead and some weird stuff goes on... Im really angry because there is 2 babbies that look the same and so whichever is heavier, that one lives and the other doesn’t get to live, I think it’s unfair, I mean I knew it was death cause it was obvious cause they were never seen again.And it’s like murder but like they don’t care about the others. I think that when jonas is grown up he’ll have to choose between twins and he’ll have the one twin and just throw the other down the shoot and the baby will meet a family out in the world. Maby it’s really the 20th centuary and the baby will grow up happy! That would be something nice for once. Or maby he’ll ask if the babbie can live so then the’ll have to cause jonas asking is like him giving an order and then he’ll ask if the laws can be changed and it will be a better community!milt

I think I know why they would do this. For one thing, if they have too much sameness, then they will all look the same, and when they all look the same and there is a baby that looks different they would most likely panick in confusion. So maybe this is the reason they are doing this. **BUT** I still thinkthis is a horrible idea!!!set

HELLO. SCHMORLANDO HERE. YOU HAVE A LOT OF INTERESTING POINTS ABOUT RELEASE. I WAS SHOCKED THE FIRST TIME I READ THE BOOK AND DISCOVERED WHAT RELEASE WAS. ONE FINAL QUESTION-- IF OUR SOCIETY WENT TO SAMENESS, WHAT IS THE **ONE** THING YOU'D MISS MOST ABOUT OUR WORLD? GOT TO GO. MY AGENT IS CALLING....

I tHink Jonas and Gabe wIll Make It to elSewere. If they didn’t then they would have a Sad ending to an awsoMe book! And theY cant do that! And that would mEan a teen and a baby would die. So yea they will make it to elseweaR Soon enough.