Giver-Question+6

Did Jonas and Gabe make it to Elsewhere? Give specific reasons why or why not.

I say they DID make it to Elsewhere, wherever that is. I believe no longer that Elsewhere is Heaven (my main evidence? The third book XD ) But other than that, I believe that they DID make it, because, even though they did have images flashing before them, I believe they were just releasing their old memories, ready to embrace the new ones with open arms. I cannot say that I believe GABE made it with Jonas, because he is just a little baby. They cannot stay in the cold for too long. Although Jonas may have lived, he is twelve, older, and more prepared with the memories. But little Gabe is barely able to be called a toddler and weak. But who knows. Maybe they both made it. I hope so, but it is not providing the evidence we need to make a solid conclusion. Maybe the family found